Sugar Hill Creamery Menu (Update 2025)
Located in New York City, Sugar Hill Creamery is a gem for ice cream enthusiasts. The menu boasts a variety of options, including single and double scoops, pints, ice cream sandwiches, sundaes, and shakes. Indulge in their Chocolate Bliss or Donut Sundae for a heavenly treat. The homemade baked goods, like the chocolate chip cookies and brownies, are a must-try.
With rave reviews from customers praising the rich flavors and friendly service, Sugar Hill Creamery stands out for its unique and innovative offerings. From vegan options to specialty flavors like Blueberry Cheesecake, each scoop is made with love and attention to detail. The cozy ambiance and welcoming staff make every visit a delight. Don't miss out on experiencing the creamy textures and exciting flavor combinations at Sugar Hill Creamery.
Ice Cream
Single Scoop
One 4 oz scoop of local, handmade ice cream.
Double Scoop
Two 3 oz scoops of local, handmade ice cream.
Triple Scoop
Three 3 oz scoops of local, handmade ice cream.
Pint
Pre-packed pint of Sugar Hill Creamery's signature and seasonal flavors.
Ice Cream Sandwich
One 3 oz scoop of local, handmade ice cream sandwich between two homemade chocolate chip cookies.
Ice Cream Sundae
Two 3 oz scoops of local, handmade ice cream layered with whipped cream, homemade brownie bits or broken cones and topped with your choice of caramel or chocolate sauce.
Chocolate Bliss
Indulge in a heavenly treat with our decadent brownie and chocolate chip cookie combo, perfectly paired with a scoop of ice cream of your choice!
Malted Shake
16 oz ice cream shake with malted powder and your choice of flavor.
Donut Sundae, Cinnamon, Milk Jam
Specialty Items
Baked Goods
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Like everything on our menu, we make our chocolate chip cookies in house. Enjoy this unique crinkle cookie, which is both soft, chewy, and packed with generous chunks of rich chocolate chips that melt in your mouth with every bite. Baked fresh daily, these cookies make a great companion to a scoop of ice cream, or enjoy two with your favorite flavor for a delicious ice cream sandwich.
Homemade Brownie
Sugar Hill Creamery's homemade brownies are a decadent delight. Made from scratch with premium cocoa powder and melted chocolate, these fudgy squares have a deep, intense chocolate flavor. Each bite satisfies your chocolate craving and are perfect addition to our signature brownie sundae.
Hot Chocolate
Our famous ice cream hot chocolate made with 64% Guayaquil dark chocolate and topped with homemade, torched marshmallow fluff.
Seasonal Items
Drinks
Evian
Still Water.
San Pellegrino
Sparkling Water.
Craft Root Beer
Enjoy this sweet, nostalgic non-alcoholic, and non-caffeinated beverage with your favorite scoop
Jarritos Mandarin
Jarritos Mandarin is a popular Mexican soda that combines sweet and tangy flavors with natural mandarin orange notes. It's made with real sugar, natural flavors, and less carbonation than other sodas. Some say it smells strongly of fresh mandarins, with a little candied smell, and is sweet but not too sweet. Others describe it as refreshing, authentic, and having a unique flavor. Jarritos Mandarin is a unique and flavorful alternative to traditional sodas.
Jarritos Tamarind
Jarritos Tamarind is a Mexican soda made with real fruit flavors, cane sugar, and natural flavors. It's lightly carbonated and has a sweet and tangy tamarind flavor with notes of caramel and bitter orange. Some say it's refreshing and not too sweet, while others describe it as having an earthy flavor. Jarritos Tamarind is caffeine-free.
Ginger Beer
Add this refreshing sparkling ginger drink to your favorite scoop