My friend has raved about Sugar Hill Creamery for a while and I was finally able to go! First impressions walking in are that it's the cutest and most inviting little shop I've been to in a while and the gentleman behind the counter was so welcoming, patient and informative. I had the hot cocoa which is topped with a torched marshmallow... that cocoa!!??!! OMG! It's like a melted chocolate bar ... rich, thick, sugary, creamy ... ALL THE THINGS! I can see why my friend raved about it for so long! I am definitely coming back to try the ice cream, coffee and to sip on a little more cocoa while it's still chilly outside. LOVE THIS PLACE!

The ultimate hot chocolate with burnt marshmallow topping! Such a delight to find this luxury $$ treat in my own neighborhood

This is the best ice cream shop in Harlem with cheerful scoopers, quick service, and a very cute space. I love their variety of flavors but my go-to is their vegan dark chocolate --it's sinfully delicious. I appreciate that they let you sample flavors before you decide. They have a great kids area too with chalk and seating.

Came here as it's rated one of the top ice cream places in nyc. They have some great flavors, I tried the dark chocolate and peach cobbler and both were great! I will say this place offers unique options! I wouldn't really go here again because of the area that it's in. Overall, great shop to try innovative flavors but wouldn't recommend visiting because of location.

Sugar Hill Creamery is a true gem! My date took me to Sugar Hill Creamery, his favorite ice cream spot in the neighborhood, and I'm so glad he did. Even though I'm lactose intolerant and probably shouldn't indulge, I'm always down for good ice cream, and this place did not disappoint! We went after dinner, and I opted for the caramel cookies and cream ice cream in a cup. It was everything my date raved about and more. The ice cream was rich, flavorful, and clearly handmade with love. You can truly taste the difference! The shop itself was cozy and well air-conditioned, with some great music playing in the background. The ice cream was so good that we ended up eating in blissful silence, just savoring every spoonful. I'll definitely be back, lactose intolerance be damned!

Really complex and rich flavor with the Lemon Meringue cake one, forgot what it's called. It's like they somehow trapped the moist and buttery sensation you get from a cake and converted it to ice cream texture, temperature, and form. Peach Cobbler flavor was solid too, doesn't really taste like processed sugary peach but rather actual tangy and slightly sweet peach. Good Icecream, would recommend.

Blueberry Cheesecake flavor is my absolute favorite flavor from this business. It's in a cute little shop, marked with famous black figures with a blue background. Workers are always friendly. A must try black owned business :)

This ice cream is amazing. Super creamy & perfect texture, high quality, amazing taste & unique fun flavors. This spot was recommended to me by lots of people, and it still managed to exceed expectations! I went twice in the span of one week and can't wait to go back. Highly recommend. The service is great too - staff is friendly and patient with people trying samples. Great ambiance inside too - really beautifully painted walls.

One day after church, a group of us decided to check out Sugar Hill Creamery. After having a sample of the Andy Griffin and the Tuma Buma, I ordered a Double scoop: Andy Griffin (vanilla bean) and Tuma Buna (Ethiopian coffee, ginger turmeric, and honey). It was everything I needed. The flavors were so rich and full of flavor. Honestly, the flavors complimented each other perfectly. I felt like although I was indulging, the calories didn't count as a way to justify my good choices...lol Of course, they counted, but a girl could dream. I am a fan of this charming, adorable spot that is doing a great service of providing high-quality, rich tasting ice cream.

I did not expect to go to a place with such interesting flavors. This place really reminded me of those small ice creameries in secondary cities like St. Louis and Detroit that have so many fun and unique flavors. They also give you a huge scoop which is great! I ordered the Cafe Touba which has a base of Senegalese Coffee with Peanut Brittle, Cardamom, and Selim Pepper Brownies mixed into it. I don't know why, but it has a very strong ginger flavor to it which I enjoyed. Each bite was so interesting as you get all these delicious flavoring combinations elevating the essentially coffee ice cream you just ordered. I wish I had 3 scoops just so I could try all the different flavors that they had. Overall, fantastic experience at Sugar Hill Creamery and I will be back for more!